Top Spots for Lobster Rolls in Portland, Maine You Must Try

Embarking on a culinary quest to uncover the best lobster roll in Portland, Maine, is akin to seeking the Holy Grail of New England’s seafood scene. With its picturesque coastline and vibrant culinary landscape, Portland has cemented its reputation as a bastion for lobster roll aficionados. The quest for the perfect lobster roll is not just about indulging in a local delicacy; it’s a deep dive into a tradition that has captivated the taste buds of locals and travelers alike. As we peel back the layers of buttered buns, fresh lobster meat, and the secret sauces that make each roll a unique masterpiece, we invite you on a gastronomic journey through the heart of Maine’s most beloved locales.

This article isn’t merely a list; it’s a curated expedition led by an insatiable curiosity and a commitment to uncovering the quintessence of Portland’s lobster roll scene. From the dockside shacks serving up generations of maritime heritage in each bite to innovative eateries that reimagine this classic dish with modern twists, our exploration is guided by an intricate understanding of what makes each roll not just good, but legendary.

As we navigate through this culinary landscape, you’ll discover not just the flavors that define Portland’s lobster rolls but the stories of the people and places behind them. This isn’t just about finding a meal; it’s about experiencing a piece of Maine’s soul, one bite at a time. So, whether you’re a seasoned lobster roll enthusiast or a curious newcomer eager to taste what the fuss is all about, this article promises not just to enlighten but to inspire your next culinary adventure. Join us as we unravel the artistry behind the best lobster rolls in Portland, Maine, and perhaps, just perhaps, you’ll find your palate forever changed by the journey.

Best Lobster Roll In Portland Maine

The best lobster roll in Portland, Maine is subjective and depends on personal preferences. However, some highly-rated options include:

1. The Highroller Lobster Co. – Known for its elevated lobster roll scene and unique offerings like lobster grilled cheese and lobster tacos.
2. Luke’s Lobster Portland Pier – Offers a robust, sweet, and buttery lobster roll with locally sourced meat and a choice of butter or mayo.
3. Portland Lobster Company – Located on Chandlers Wharf, this spot offers fresh seafood and a classic lobster roll with tail and claw meat, lettuce, and mayo.
4. Bite Into Maine – Known for its seasonal truck in Fort Williams Park and year-round location in Scarborough, offering three styles of rolls: Maine, Connecticut, and Picnic.
5. Eventide Oyster Co. – Famous for its brown butter lobster roll served on a homemade steamed bun.
6. Becky’s Diner – A local institution offering a classic lobster roll with a quarter-pound of fresh-shucked lobster meat and a side of crispy fries.
7. Susan’s Fish-n-Chips – A local seafood treasure with a lobster BLT served on a toasted sesame bun.

These are just a few of the many great options for lobster rolls in Portland, Maine.

Key Venues Offering Lobster Rolls –Unique Culinary Creations

Key Venues Offering Lobster Rolls -Unique Culinary Creations
Key Venues Offering Lobster Rolls -Unique Culinary Creations

The Highroller Lobster Co.

The Highroller Lobster Co. food truck is known for its innovative takes on the lobster roll, with choices like:

  • Lobster Grilled Cheese
  • Lobster Roll with Garlic Aioli
  • Lobster Roll with Lemon Dijon Sauce

They pride themselves on fusing culinary invention with the fresh catch of the day.

Bite Into Maine

Situated along the Cape Elizabeth coastline, Bite Into Maine offers an array of lobster roll options:

  • Traditional Maine-Style Lobster Roll
  • Picnic Lobster Roll with Celery and Homemade Salad Dressing
  • Surf & Turf Lobster Roll with Beef Tenderloin

Their seasonal operations mean visiting at the right time is key for the best lobster.

Classic and Quintessential Experiences

Luke’s Lobster

Luke’s Lobster sits practically on the Portland docks, right next to the lobster buying stations. This allows them to hand-pick the days catch for their straightforward lobster rolls:

  • Chilled Lobster Roll with Lemon Butter
  • Warm Lobster Roll with Butter
  • Crab and Lobster Roll

It’s the essence of Maine lobster rolls steps from the source.

Portland Lobster Company

Overlooking the Portland harbor, the Portland Lobster Company pairs fresh local seafood with picturesque views of the waterfront. Their traditional lobster rolls capture the scenery in each bite.

Award-Winning and Critically Acclaimed Spots

Eventide Oyster Co.

Eventide Oyster Co. gained national acclaim for its brown butter lobster roll, taking home the title of “Best Lobster Roll” at NYC’s Lobster Rumble multiple times. Their poached lobster roll also garners rave reviews.

Becky’s Diner

For over 90 years, Becky’s Diner has served as a local institution for Maine fare. Their straightforward lobster roll has earned countless loyal fans for its genuine fresh flavors.

Atmospheric Dining

Boone’s Fish House & Oyster Room

Boone’s Fish House offers harborfront dining across two floors of decks, allowing patrons to watch working lobster boats while enjoying lobster rolls with homemade mayo or drawn butter.

The Porthole

A casual, long-standing waterfront establishment, The Porthole serves traditional Maine lobster rolls alongside stunning views overlooking the Portland harbor and nearby islands.

Innovative and Diverse Offerings

Three Dollar Deweys

This gastropub puts a creative twist on their lobster grilled cheese, made with mascarpone cheese and served with a side of creamy seafood bisque for dipping.

J’s Oyster

J’s Oyster takes a straightforward approach to their lobster roll, served chilled with lettuce on a toasted bun, but allows patrons to customize the mayo for their desired flavor.

Considerations for Visitors

Pricing Information

Lobster roll prices tend to range from $12-$22 across Portland, with many spots falling around the $15-$18 range. Expect higher prices for more premium ingredients or creative flavors.

Atmosphere and Setting

Some spots like Boone’s Fish House offer waterfront dining with scenic views, while others like The Highroller Lobster Co. serve rolls from a food truck. Dining format impacts overall experience.

Seasonal Offerings and Hours

Certain spots like Bite Into Maine operate seasonally, only open during the summer months when fresh lobster is plentiful. Off-season visits may lead to limited or no availability for lobster.

Special Features

Patios and waterfront decks at restaurants like The Porthole allow guests to dine with views of the harbor. Luke’s Lobster sits directly next door to active buying stations.

Additional Insights

Customer Favorites and Recommendations

  • Eventide Oyster Co: Brown Butter Lobster Roll, Oysters
  • Luke’s Lobster: Crab and Lobster Roll, Lobster Bisque
  • Boone’s Fish House: Fried Oyster Dinner, Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Accessibility and Parking

Most spots offer decently accessible parking, while venues like Luke’s Lobster and The Porthole benefit from close proximity to public lots or street parking.

Health and Safety Measures

Venues have implemented additional sanitization procedures, physical distancing guidelines, and mobile ordering options to allow for safe dining during COVID-19.

Contact Information and Reservations

Reservations strongly recommended for busy times at all locations. Highroller and Bite Into Maine food trucks open on limited schedules.


Portland’s diversity across lobster roll styles, settings, and dining formats makes tasting through the options both an exciting culinary adventure and a means of discovering one’s ideal flavors and experiences. From harborside views to food truck fare, Picnic Rolls to Lobster Grilled Cheese, this guide outlines the many paths forfinding that perfect, crave-worthy lobster roll in Portland.

Leave a Comment